Re: Health insurance notices that insurance is doubling
Posted: Sat Oct 04, 2025 6:20 am
I always think about how the "health care for undocumented immigrants" thing is always blown up and misrepresented. In fairness though, the tangle of laws that govern all that make it pretty confusing for a normal person trying to figure out what the deal really is.
The 1986 EMTALA law requires that emergency rooms at nearly all hospital treat anyone who shows up, regardless of the ability to pay and regardless of immigration status. I'd note that a Republican (Ronald Wilson Reagan) was president in 1986 and he advocated pretty strongly for this law.
From a practical standpoint, in a medical emergency, a lot of people might not have access to documents that prove their citizenship with them in the ER and getting those documents together would take time. In a medical emergency when lifesaving care is required you often won't have that time. So you have a choice between letting people you might not approve of getting emergency health care and letting people who otherwise would be entitled to that health care die because their paperwork might not be in order.
The 1986 EMTALA law requires that emergency rooms at nearly all hospital treat anyone who shows up, regardless of the ability to pay and regardless of immigration status. I'd note that a Republican (Ronald Wilson Reagan) was president in 1986 and he advocated pretty strongly for this law.
From a practical standpoint, in a medical emergency, a lot of people might not have access to documents that prove their citizenship with them in the ER and getting those documents together would take time. In a medical emergency when lifesaving care is required you often won't have that time. So you have a choice between letting people you might not approve of getting emergency health care and letting people who otherwise would be entitled to that health care die because their paperwork might not be in order.